Report No. 275
Legal Framework: BCCI Vis-à-Vis Right to Information Act, 2005
Table of Contents
Chapters |
Title |
Pages |
I |
Background |
1-23 |
A. A Brief History of Cricket in India |
1 |
|
B. History of BCCI |
3 |
|
C. Evolution of the Right to Information (RTI) in India |
5 |
|
(a) Right to Information Laws in States |
9 |
|
1) Tamil Nadu |
9 |
|
2) Goa |
10 |
|
3) Madhya Pradesh |
12 |
|
4) Rajasthan |
13 |
|
5) Karnataka |
14 |
|
6) Maharashtra |
15 |
|
7) Delhi |
16 |
|
8) Uttar Pradesh |
17 |
|
9) Jammu & Kashmir |
17 |
|
10) Assam |
18 |
|
(b) RTI Movement - social and national milieu |
19 |
|
II |
Reference to Commission and Reports of Various Committees |
24-30 |
A. NCRWC Report, 2002 |
24 |
|
B. 179th Report of the Law Commission of India, 2001 |
26 |
|
C. Report of the Pranab Mukherjee Committee, 2001 |
26 |
|
D. Report of the Working Group for Drafting of the National Sports Development Bill 2013 |
27 |
|
E. Lodha Committee Report, 2016 |
28 |
|
III |
Concept of State under Article 12 of the Constitution of India - Analysis of the term 'Other authorities' |
31-36 |
IV |
RTI - Human Rights Perspective |
37-55 |
a. Right to Information as a Human Right |
38 |
|
- Constitutional position |
40 |
|
b. Application to Private Entities |
44 |
|
(i) State Responsibility |
45 |
|
(ii) Duties of Private Bodies |
46 |
|
c. Human Rights and Sports |
48 |
|
V |
Perusal of the terms "Public Authority" and "Public Functions" and "Substantially financed" |
56-82 |
1. Public Authority |
56 |
|
a. National Perspective |
56 |
|
b. International Perspective |
58 |
|
c. Interpretation of the word 'includes' |
61 |
|
d. Interpretation of the word 'control' |
64 |
|
2. Public Functions |
67 |
|
a. National Perspective |
67 |
|
b. International Perspective |
70 |
|
3. Substantially Financed |
71 |
|
VI |
Analysis of the Legal Status of BCCI |
83-96 |
- Whether BCCI should be 'State' within the meaning of Article 12? |
85 |
|
- Minority view in the Zee Telefilms case |
86 |
|
- BCCI - Performing 'Public Functions'? |
91 |
|
- BCCI - a National Sports Federation? |
93 |
|
- BCCI - 'Substantially Financed' by the Government? |
94 |
|
VII |
Conclusions and Recommendations |
97-100 |
List of Cases |
101-107 |
|
List of Cases |
108-110 |
|
Annexures |
I. MoA of BCCI |
111 |
II. Reply of Hon'ble Minister of Youth Affairs and Sports to unstarred question 2097 in the Lok Sabha |
117 |
|
III. Ministry of Youth Affairs and Sports, Department of Sports' letter number F.No.36-2/2010-SP-II, dated March 30, 2010 'Declaring National Sports Federations as Public Authority' |
120 |