Surinder Singh &
Ors. Vs. State of Punjab & Ors.  INSC 1479 (1 September 2008)
JURISDICTION CIVIL APPEAL NO. 5473 OF 2008 [Arising out of SLP(C) NO.10947 of
2006] SURINDER SINGH & ORS. .......APPELLANT(S) Versus
granted. Heard the parties.
appellants, who are the residents of a residential area, filed a writ petition
objecting to the construction of a hospital coming up in one of the plots (Plot
No.39) on the ground that no hospital can come up in a residential plot in a
residential area. The High Court, by interim order dated 19.1.2006, granted
stay of further construction.
26.5.2006, while admitting the writ petition, the High Court vacated the
interim stay but directed that any construction on the site shall be subject to
the final decision in the writ petition. It also recorded the undertaking given
on behalf of the fourth respondent that in case the appellants succeed in the
writ petition, he shall demolish the construction raised by him. The Court also
directed that the matter should be listed for final disposal within one year.
grievance of the appellants is that if construction which is proceeding at a
fast pace is completed and if the hospital starts functioning, then the very
purpose of the writ petition will be defeated.
find that the High Court itself had directed that the petition should be listed
for final disposal within one year. As on date, more than two years have
In the circumstances,
we feel that the interim order requires a slight modification to safeguard the
interest of both parties.
therefore request the High Court to hear and dispose of the writ petition early
preferably within four months. Pending final decision, the respondents shall
not commence any kind of activity in the building under construction even if it
is completed before the decision in the writ petition. With the above
modification to the impugned order, this appeal is disposed of.
( R.V. RAVEENDRAN )
Pages: 1 2