Shand Pipe Industries Ltd Vs. M/S. Hind Mosaic & Cement Works & Ors  INSC
328 (3 March 2008)
S.H. KAPADIA & B. SUDERSHAN REDDY O R D E R CIVIL APPEAL NO. 1759 OF 2008 (Arising out of SLP(C)No. 4685/2008)
Heard learned counsel on both sides.
In this case, patent stood granted in favour of the respondents on
2.12.2006. Till then, appellant herein had not opposed the grant of patent.
On 2.7.2007 suit was instituted in the District Court which stood
transferred to the High Court when the appellant herein filed its counter claim
When the matter came before the Single Judge it was held that the invention
was not patentable. Aggrieved by the order of the Single Judge refusing interim
relief the matter was carried in appeal before the Division Bench.
By the impugned order interim relief has been granted by the Division Bench.
Hence this civil appeal at the behest of the defendant.
Having gone through the impugned order, we are of the view that the Division
Bench has not analized the scheme of the Patents Act, particularly in the
context of Sec.13 (4) read with Secs. 47 and 48 of that Act, particularly the
effect of counter claim. This analysis was important as the Division Bench was
required to consider the effect of the registration of the patent.
-2- In the circumstances we set aside the impugned order of the Division
Bench restore O.J. Appeal No. 201 of 2007 and and remit the matter for fresh
consideration in accordance with law. We keep contentions on both sides open.
We express no opinion on the merits of the case. As the matter is of importance
and urgency we direct the Division Bench to hear and decide the matter as
expeditiously as possible and not later than four weeks from today.
The appeal is disposed of accordingly.