Tulsibhai
Jivabhai Changani Vs. State of Gujarat [2000] INSC 643 (12 December 2000)
M.B.Saha,
S.N.Variava
a L.I.T.J
S. N.
VARIAVA, J.
Leave
granted. This Appeal is against an Order dated 29th August, 2000. Briefly stated the facts are as follows:
On 9th September, 1996 the Appellant has been convicted
and sentenced for offences under Sections 198, 420 and 471 I.P.C. on the ground
that he knew that a Marksheet produced by him was false and still he used that Marksheet
for gaining admission to Polytechnic Course in 1986. The trial court whilst
convicting the Appellant has noted that it was not proved that the Marksheet
had been forged by the Appellant. The trial court, however, held that there was
a possibility that the Appellant had either himself or through somebody else
got the Marksheet amended. The trial Court found that the Appellant was aware
that this was not the correct Marksheet and had still used it to gain
admission.
The
trial Court, therefore, convicted the Appellant as set out above. The Sessions
Court dismissed the Appeal of the Appellant. A Revision was filed before the
High Court of Gujarat. The High Court by the impugned Judgment refused to
interfere. It dismissed the Revision. Hence this Appeal.
We
have heard the parties. In our view it has been proved beyond a reasonable
doubt that the Appellant used the duplicate certificate with changes, as a true
certificate knowing it to be false in material particular and thereby got
admission. Therefore we see no reason to interfere with the conviction. However
looking to the nature of the offence and the fact that the Appellant's past and
present records has been good and the fact that he has already lost his career
and is now married we reduce the sentence to that already under gone. The
Appellant shall be set at liberty forthwith if not required in any other case.
Back