Chawla Vs. Metropolitan Magistrate & Ors  INSC 487 (1 May 1997)
C. SEN, K.S. PARIPOORNAN
O R D
E R This case arises of alleged ill-treatment of Mrs.
Chawla by her husband and her father. The case is going on since 29th July 1995. Smt. Anamika Chawla came up
against the order passed by the Metropolitan Magistrate on 29th July, 1995 ordering to be admitted to Delhi
Psychiatry Centre, 35, Defence Enclave, Vikas Marg, New Delhi, for observation and treatment.
This Order was passed with undue haste even without seeing the alleged patient
Medical certificates were produced from Dr. Sunil Mittal and Dr. S. C. Malik.
The case of the petitioner, Mrs. Chawla, is that neither of the two doctors had
ever met her or examined her.
allegation appears to be true.
the application was moved by Mrs. Anamika Chawla, she was staying in Guild of
Service Hostel in New
warden of the Hostel appeared in person and stated that she found Mrs. Chawla's
behaviour normal. She was on friendly terms with the other inmates of the
hostel. It was also recorded in the Order of this Court held on 3rd August,
1993 that this Court had personally questioned the petitioner and had not
noticed any mental aberration bus since the medical certificates had been
produced before the Magistrate, we wanted to examine the case in greater
case has now gone on a number of days. We heard the Doctors and examined the
reports heard all the parties Mrs Chawla has appeared before us personally on a
number of days. We have spoken to her on all these days. We have not noticed
the slightest abnormality in her behaviour.
tried to bring about a reconciliation between the husband and wife but
unfortunately no reconciliation could be brought about. The parties were
directed to undergo counselling which has gone on for some time. We have seen
records sent by the counsellor. We are of the view that no useful purpose will
be served by prolonging this case any further.
hold that there was no basis for passing the impugned order dated 20th July, 1995 by the Metropolitan Magistrate. The
Order is quashed. The Writ Petition filed in this Court by Anamika Chawla is
disposed of finally as above. There will be no order as to costs.