Union Carbide India Ltd. Vs. State of Andhra Pradesh  INSC 181 (20 March 1995)
Jagdish Saran (J) Verma, Jagdish Saran (J) Bharucha S.P. (J) Paripoornan, K.S.(J)
J.S. Verma, J.:
1995 SCC Supl. (2) 267 JT 1995 (3) 218 1995 SCALE (2)355
appeals by special leave are against the judgment dated 5.2.1976 in Tax
Revision Case Nos. 18 and 19 of 1975, by the High Court of Andhra Pradesh. The
two question answered by the High Court relate to the assessment years 1968-69
and 1969-70 which are:
Whether dry cell batteries manufactured by the assessees are exigible to tax
under Entry No. 3 or Entry No. 38 of the First Schedule to the Andhra Pradesh
General Sales Tax Act, 1957? (2) Whether the arc carbons manufactured by the
assesses are exigible to tax under Entry No. 4 or Entry No. 38 of the First
Schedule to the Andhra Pradesh General Sales Tax Act, 1957? The Tribunal held
that the "dry cell batteries" are taxable under Entry No. 38 except
only those which are specified for use in transistors, which alone are taxable
under Entry No. 3; and the "arc carbons" are taxable under Entry No.
4. The revisions filed by the assessee have been dismissed by the High Court.
Hence these appeals by special leave. The connected matters are similar and are
disposed of in 221 terms of this judgment.
relevant entries with reference to which the above questions are to be decided,
Wireless reception At the point 12 paise instruments and apparatus, of first
sale in the radios,and radio hones, in the state rupee electrical valves, accum-
ulators, amplifiers and loud-speakers and spare parts and accessories
equipment -do- 12 paise including cameras, projectors in the and sound
recording and rupee reproducing equipment lenses, film and parts and
accessories required for use therewith.
electrical goods, -do- 8 paise instruments, apparatus and in the appliances
including fans rupee and lighting bulbs electrical earthenware and procelain and
all other accessories. " The assessee contends for taxing of these
articles at the lower rate under Entry No. 38 and not at the higher rate under
Entry Nos. 3 or 4.
shall first consider the question relating to "arc carbons". The only
argument on behalf of the assessee is that the carbon is used up and,
therefore, it cannot be an accessory of the equipment specified in Entry No. 4.
On this basis, the assessee claims that arc carbon used in the equipment is
taxable under Entry No. 38 at a lesser rate.
High Court following its earlier decision held that arc carbons manufactured by
the assessee were assessable under Entry No. 4 and not Entry No. 38. That view
of the Andhra Pradesh High Court has been approved by this Court in Annapurna
Carbon Industries Co. vs. State of Andhra Pradesh,  37 S.T.C. 378, and it
was held that arc carbons fell within Entry No. 4 of the First Schedule to the
Act. It was held by this Court that:
The meaning of this entry can only be satisfactorily determined in the light of
language of the entry itself considered in the context in which it occurs.
entry No. 4 occurs in a schedule in which descriptions of goods to be taxed
indicate that the expression "required for use therewith" has been
employed for equipment or accessories connected with the main purpose.
instance, in entry No. 5, the expression 222 occurs at the end as follows:
and other cameras and enlargers, lenses, films and plates, paper and cloth and
other parts and accessories required for use therewith. " Apparently, the
deciding factor is the predominant or ordinary purpose or use. It is not enough
to show that the article can be put to other uses also. It is its general or
predominant user which seems to determine the category in which an article will
entry No. 3 for "wireless reception instruments and apparatus"
includes "electrical valves, accumulators, amplifiers and loud-speakers
and spare parts and accessories thereof'. The words "Parts thereof" are
used in several entries, such as entry No. 6 for clocks, timepieces and
watches, entry No. 10 for dictaphones and other similar apparatus for recording
sound and entry No. 11 for sound transmitting equipment such as telephones and
in indicating the nature of entries, amidst which entry No, 4 occurs is to show
that some precision has been attempted in making the entries. When it was
intended to confine the entry to particular gadgets and "parts
thereof" the entry said so. Of course, even where an entry relates to
parts manufactured for use for a particular kind of instrument or gadget only,
the article, manufactured to serve as a part of a particular kind of apparatus
would not cease to be covered by the intended entry simply because a purchaser
makes some other use of it. We have to find the intention of the framers of the
schedule in making the entry in each case. The best guide to their intentions
is the language actually employed by them.
find that the term "accessories" is used in the schedule to describe
goods which may have been manufactured for use as an aid or addition. A sense
in which the word "accessory" is used is given in Webster's Third New
International Dictionary as follows:
object or device that is not essential in itself but that adds to the beauty,
convenience, or effectiveness of something else". Other meanings given
there are :
or secondary to something of greater or primary importance";
of several mechanical devices that assist in operating or controlling to tone
resources of an organ". "Accessories" are not necessarily
confined to particular machines for which they may serve as aids, The same item
may be an accessory of more than one kind of instrument.
will be noticed that the entry we have to interpret includes "parts"
as well as "accessories" which are required for use in projectors or
other cinematographic equipment.
think that The Andhra Pradesh High Court correctly held that the main use of
the are carbons under consideration was duly proved to be that of production of
powerful light used in projectors in cinemas. The fact that they can also be
used for searchlights, signaling, stage lighting, or where powerful lighting
for photography or other purposes may be required, could not detract from the
classification to which the carbon arcs belong. That is determined by their
ordinary or commonly known purpose or user. This, as already observed by us, is
evident from the fact that they are known as "cinema are carbons" in
the Market. This finding was enough, in our opinion to justify the view taken
by the Andhra Pradesh High Court that the goods under consideration are covered
by the relevant entry No. 4. " (emphasis supplied) (at pages 380-81) 223
plea on behalf of the assessee for reconsideration of the decision of this
Court in Annapurna Carbon Industries Co. (supra) was made. We find no ground to
accept that submission. We may add that the decision has held the field for all
these years and we do not find any reason to doubt the correctness of that
decision. It must, therefore, be held that the decision of the High Court that
arc carbons are taxable under Entry No. 4 of the First Schedule to the Act does
not call for any interference.
now consider the question relating to dry battery cells. The matters involving
this question are of two broad categories. One category relates to the period
prior to certain amendments made in the Act in 1976 while the other category of
matters relates to the period subsequent to that amendment. For the period
prior to the 1976 amendment, the dry cell batteries only of Union Carbide India
Ltd. which bore on it the mark "for transistors" were held to be
taxable under Entry No. 3 at a higher rate while the multi- purpose dry cell
batteries of all the assessees which did not bear any such mark were held to be
taxable at the lesser rate under Entry No. 38. Accordingly, for the period
prior to 1976, the only aggrieved assessee is the Union Carbide India Ltd. in
respect of its batteries bearing the mark "for transistors" which
were assessed at the higher rate under Entry No. 3 while the State is aggrieved
by assessment of the remaining dry cell batteries of all assessees under Entry
No. 38. For this reason, there are cross appeals by the Union Carbide India
Ltd, and the State relating to the period prior to 1976 amendment.
the post-1976 period, the High Court has held that all dry cell batteries,
after the amendments in the Act, are taxable only under Entry No. 38. Accordingly,
the State alone has preferred the appeals in this behalf for the post- 1976
the appeals are considered together since they involve for decision the common
question of taxability of dry cell batteries. The contention of the learned
counsel appearing for the assessee is that the dry cell batteries are taxable
only under Entry No. 38 for the entire period.
other hand, the contention on behalf of the State Government is that all such
batteries are taxable throughout only under Entry No. 3. In the alternative, it
was urged that after the 1976 amendment effective from 1.9.1976, the dry cell
batteries are taxable under Entry No. 137 as it then stood but not under Entry
No. 38. It was submitted that Entry No. 3 is attracted because dry cell
batteries are "accessories" of wireless reception instruments etc.
even if not "accumulators"; and that it is not
"accessories" of "electrical goods" due to which Entry No.
38 is excluded.
short, the contention on behalf of the State is that a "dry cell
battery" is either an "accumulator" or "storage
battery" or an "accessory" of wireless reception instruments
etc. to fall under Entry No. 3 throughout or Entry No. 137 w.e.f. 1.9.1976 but
not an "accessory" of "electrical goods" to fall under Entry
No. 38. The question for decision, therefore, is whether the view taken that
dry cell batteries fall within Entry No.38 is incorrect on the grounds urged by
the State. Only in respect of Union Carbide India Ltd,. for the pre-1976
period, the question also is : Whether the dry cell batteries marked "for
transistors" were wrongly assessed to be taxable under Entry No, 3 instead
of Entry 224 No.38?
this stage, the relevant entries as they stood after the amendment made in 1976
and 1985 may also be quoted:
effect from 1.9.1976:- "3. Wireless reception At the point 12 paise
instruments and apparatus, of first sale in the radios and radio in the state
rupee gramophones, electrical valves, accumulators, amplifiers and loudspeakers
and spare parts and accessories thereof. (1003)
All kinds of electrical -do- 8 paise goods, instruments, apparatus in the and
appliances that is to say - rupee (i) Wires, holders, plugs, switches,
electrical earthenware and porcelain ware;
Casings, cappings, reapers, bends, junction boxes, meter-boxes, switch boxes,
meter- boards and switch boards other those made of wood;
Electrical fans, lighting bulbs, torches, fluorescent tubes and their fittings,
like chokes and starters and other parts and accessories thereof, (iv)
Electrical grinders, mixers, blenders, hair driers, shavers, washing machines
cooking ranges, boilers, ovens,geysers, gener- ators, transformers and parts
and accessories thereof, (v) Electronic systems, instruments apparatus,
appliances including electronic cash register- ing indexing card- punching,
franking and addressing machines, computers of analog and digital varieties,
one record units, oscilloscopes and other electronic equipment and material and
parts and accessories thereof;
225 137. Electrical storage At the point 12 paise batteries and parts of first
in the thereof of including sale in the rupee containers, covers and plates
(1137) state With effect from 1.7.1985:-- 152. Dry batteries or cells At the
point *(10) paise *(and parts and accessories of first in the thereof). sale in
the rupee *Rate of tax on item 152 reduced from 11 paise to 10 paise and the bracked
words added by G.O.Ms.No.630, Rev., dt.30.5.1986 w.e.f. 1.6.1986 and later by
Act 19 of 1986 w.e.f. 1.8.1986 The subsequent amendments show that with Entry
No. 152 specifically providing for "dry batteries or cells" while
Entry No. 3 remained the same, since then "dry batteries or cells"
cannot come under Entry No. 3 in view of the specific Entry No. 152. The question
is whether prior to the specific provision being made in Entry No. 152 for dry
batteries or cells, Entry No. 3 had to be preferred or it was Entry No. 137 w.e.f
1.9.1976 which included "dry batteries or cells". To come under Entry
No. 137 which is the alternative argument advanced on behalf of the State
Government, dry batteries or cells must fall within the meaning of
"storage battery" and for attracting Entry No. 3 it must fall within
the expressions "accumulators" or "accessories thereof", We
shall presently show that dry batteries or cells arc not "storage
batteries" or "accumulators". The real question therefore would
be whether they can be called "accessories" of wireless reception
instruments etc." to fall within Entry No. 3. This is because the expression
is "accessories thereof".
9. In Hamlyn
All-Colour Science Encyclopedia the "accumulators" are described as:
accumulator does not make electricity in the way that the dry battery does.
Electricity has to be put in before any can be taken out. The same amount of
electricity can be obtained from an accumulator as was put into it." On
the other hand dry batteries are called a primary cell which is different from
an accumulator, secondary cell or storage battery.
Chambers Science and Technology Dictionary, "accumulator" is defined
cell which can be charged and discharged. On charge, when an electric current
is passed through it into the positive and out of the negative terminals
(according to the conventional direction of flow of current), electrical energy
is converted into chemical 226 energy. The process is reversed on discharge,
the chemical energy, less losses both in potential and current, being converted
into useful electrical energy, Accumulators therefore form a useful portable
supply of electric power, but have the disadvantages of being heavy and of
being at best 70% efficient. More often known as battery, also called
reversible cell, secondary cell, storage battery" and storage battery is
mentioned to be the same as an accumulator.
cells and primary batteries or dry batteries or cells are understood in common
parlance as well as in technology to be different from accumulators or storage
The New Encyclopedia Britannica, Vol.1, at page 963 , it is stated that,
"There are two major type of voltaic cells: primary batteries and
secondary, or storage, batteries. (The latter are sometimes also called
accumulators.) Primary cells are constructed in such a way that only one
continuous or intermittent discharge can be obtained. Secondary devices, on the
other hand, are constructed so that they can be discharged and then recharged
to approximately their original state. The charging process is the reverse of
the discharge process; therefore, the electrode reactions in these batteries
must be reversible.
batteries" are defined as "Several varieties of primary cells are
available. These include dry, wet, and solid electrolyte. Dry cells are not
actually dry but contain an aqueous electrolyte that is unspillable or
immobilized. Many of these cells are sealed to prevent seepage of the
electrolyte or reaction products. Common examples of such primary batteries arc
acidic dry cells (e.g. carbon-zinc cells), used in flashlights, toys, and
certain transistorized portable radios; alkaline dry cells, employed in
cameras, tape records, and electric razors, and mercury cells, utilized in aids
and photo- graphic flash guns." and "Secondary batteries" are
defined as "Such batteries consist of an assemblage of several identical
voltaic cells. Of the various types of storage batteries available, the
lead-acid type is the most widely used.
serves as the power source for the electrical systems of many kinds of motor
vehicles, particularly automobiles and trucks.
also commonly used to provide electricity for emergency lighting and
this reason, dry batteries or cells cannot be treated as "storage
batteries" for the purpose of Entry No. 137 or " accumulators"
for the purpose of Entry No. 3.
expression "accessories thereof" in Entry No. 3 indicates that Entry
No. 3 can be attracted only if the dry batteries or cells can be treated as
accessories of the wire reception instruments etc. specified in Entry No. 3 or
else they would fall under Entry No. 38 as "'other accessories" of
"all electrical goods" being the residuary entry. The dry cells or
batteries marked for use in transistors as is the case of some such batteries
manufactured by the Union Carbide India Ltd. alone during the pre1976 period,
may fall under Entry No. 3 as held by the High Court. However, multi-purpose
batteries, not specified for use in transistors alone cannot be treated as
"accessories thereof" of wireless reception instruments etc. for the purpose
227 of Entry No. 3.
Carbon Industries Co. significance is attached to use of the word
"thereof" and it was indicated that the deciding factor is the
predominant or ordinary purpose or use and it is not enough to show that the
articles can be put to other uses also. It was held therein that the general or
predominant user seems to determine the category in which an article will fall.
On a comparison made between the different entries in which the term
"accessories" is used in the Schedule to describe goods, it was shown
that the word was construed taking into account the fact whether the goods have
been manufactured for use as an aid or addition to any of the specified
articles in that entry or not. It was also pointed out that when it was
intended to confine the entry to particular gadgets and particulars thereof,
the entry said so; and, therefore, the expresssion "accessories thereof
'must mean the general or predominant user of the article only as an accessory
of one of the specified items mentioned in that entry Applying &a test, it
cannot be held that dry batteries or cells which were not marked "for
transistors" and were multi-purpose cells were manufactured for
predominant use as accessories of the wireless reception instruments etc. to
fall under Entry No. 3 SD that they could not be treated as "other
accessories" of "all electrical goods' for the purpose of attracting
Easy No. 38.
this stage it is also useful to refer to a clarification made by the Board of
Revenue by a circular dated 7-1.1977 which reads as follows:
Board of Revenue (C.T.) Hyderabad D7-1-1977 Shri A. Krishnaswamy ,
I.A.S., Commissioner of Commercial Taxes.
Andhra Pradesh General Sales Tax Act, 1957 Rate of tax on dry battery cells
Representation dated 27.9.1976 from M/s Indo National Limited, Nellore- The
trade has requested the Board to clarify be rue of tax applicable to dry
battery cells. battery cells.
Board has examined the issue and is of the view that dry battery cells would be
of two types :
Those labelled for a special use such as transistor batteries. The rate of tax
would depend on the rate leviable on the goods for which they are labelled as
being an accessory.
case of transistor batteries, they would be subjected to tax as accessories of radious
Those that are not labelled for special use, such dry cells would be liable 1st
Schedule to the Andhra Pradesh General Sales Tax Act 1957, i.e. `Electrical
Goods' liable to tax at 8% at the point of 1st sale in the State.
Asstt. Commissioner (CT)" 228 (at page 120 from paperbook of C.A.Nos.4537-
39/1986) The above circular is of significance to indicate the manner in which
these entries were understood and construed even by the Department which is in
accord with the construction made of the entries by the High Court.
the above reasons, we do not find any infirmity in the view taken by the High
Court on any of the two questions which it has decided. There is no ground to
interfere in any of these appeals.
all the appeals and the special leave petition are dismissed. No costs.