Court Legal Aid Committee Vs. State of M.P  INSC 306 (10 May 1994)
S. (J) Mohan, S. (J) Mukherjee M.K. (J)
1994 SCC (5) 27
After hearing the learned counsel and perusing all the relevant records we are
clearly of the opinion that in order semblance of hope may be instilled in the
lives of these unfortunate mentally ill, presently put up in Gwalior Mental
Asylum, we direct the implementation of the report, dated 2-9-1993, made out by
a Committee consisting of Dr Channabasavanna, Dr Rattemna Raju, Dr Satish, Dr Murali,
Dr Sameer and Prof. R. Srinivasa 28 Murthi of Nimhans, Bangalore. In
implementation of this report no financial constraint shall be pleaded nor will
be allowed to be pleaded.
We-are informed by Mr Muralidhar, learned counsel for the petitioner that there
is uncivilised practice of chaining of these inmates solely for the reason that
they are likely to fall down either from cots or otherwise, if they are not
chained. We strongly condemn this practice.
are better methods to avoid such accidents. They could be restored to instead
of this cruel practice of chaining them and making them miserable.
are also informed by the learned counsel that some of the inmates are naked without
even piece of apparel on them. The State shall at once look into this and take
up remedial measures post haste.
Generally speaking that these inmates also must be treated as human beings
cannot be over emphasised.
we would like to draw the attention of the Government to the orders passed in Rakesh
Chandra Narayan v. State of Bihar1 and to
carry out the obligations laid down therein.
Concerning of all the above a report shall be submitted within 3 months from
Copy of this order shall be forwarded to the Chief Secretary as well as to the
Superintendent Gwalior Mental Asylum.
Call after the report is submitted.