& Ors. Vs. Govt. of India Rep. by Secy. to Govt. & Ors  INSC 1184
(9 July 2009)
SUPREME COURT OF INDIA CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION CIVIL APPEAL NO. 4203 OF
2009 (@SPECIAL LEAVE PETITION (CIVIL)NO.21050 OF 2005) B.MAYURI & ORS.
Appellant(s) VERSUS GOVT. OF INDIA REP.BY SECY. TO GOVT. & ORS.
Respondent(s) WITH CIVIL APPEAL NO.4204 OF 2009 @ SLP(C)NO.21341/2005 CIVIL
APPEAL NO.4205 OF 2009 @ SLP(C)NO.173 OF 2006 CIVIL APPEAL NOS.4206-4207 OF
2009 @ SLP(C)NOS.26105-26106/2005 CIVIL APPEAL NOS.4208-4209 OF 2009 @
SLP(C)NOS.26103-26104/2005 CIVIL APPEAL NO.4210 OF 2009 @ SLP(C)NO.26101/2005
Heard both sides.
These appeals have been filed by the various colleges where the
studies for Indian system of medicine of homeopathy etc. are being imparted.
Some of the appeals have been filed by the students and some are filed by the
Association of Colleges where this course of studies is pursued. The students
were admitted in these colleges for the academic years 2004-05 and 2005-06. In
the State of Tamil Nadu, a Notification was issued by the Health and Family
Welfare Department to the effect that the students who join in these
professional colleges should obtain (a) a minimum of 60% marks in Biology,
Botany and Zoology taken together and (b) a minimum of 60% marks in each of the
subjects of Physics and Chemistry and an aggregate of the percentage of marks
in (a) and (b) should not be less than 140 out of 200 marks.
the State Government 2 prescribed minimum marks for various categories such as
open competition, B.C., M.B.C., S.C./S.T. Etc. For the year 2004-05, a
Notification was issued in the month of October, but by that time admissions
are over. As regards 2005-06, about 75 students had been admitted, who did not
have this requisite percentage of marks. We are told that these students have
also now completed their admission. Learned counsel appearing for the
petitioners has submitted that, as per the Central Council of India Medicine
(Minimum Standards of Education in Indian Medicine) Regulations, 1986, minimum
marks prescribed is 50%, as against 60% marks notified by the Health and Family
Welfare Department of the State Government. Of course, the State can prescribe
high percentage of marks for admission to the courses for various colleges in
the State. But these courses are not much sought after by the students and
sometimes there is difficulty in getting sufficient number of students for
these courses as most of the students either join in Engineering or medical
courses. As regards the students of 2004-05, Notification was issued belatedly.
But we do not think that this Notification should be made applicable to such
For the students of 2005-06, only 25 students were not strictly
qualified as per the Notification. But they have also secured more than 50% of
the marks as stipulated in the Central Government Notification and we are told
that they have already completed their courses. We do not think 3 that they
should be disqualified at this stage. Accordingly, we hold that these students
should also declared to be qualified to join for the courses they had opted. In
the circumstances, these appeals are disposed of with the direction that the
students shall be treated as qualified to join the courses. No costs.
...............CJI. (K.G. BALAKRISHNAN)
.................J. (P. SATHASIVAM)
9TH JULY, 2009.