Kumar Sanghvi Vs. Kamalabai & Ors.  INSC 1336 (31 July 2009)
APPELLATE JURISDICTION Contempt Petition (C) No. 211 of 2008 in SLP (C) No.
17486 of 2007 Anil Kumar Sanghvi ...Petitioner VERSUS Kamalabai & Ors.
This is an application for initiating a contempt proceeding
against the respondents for not complying with the order dated 1st of October,
2007 passed in SLP (C) No17486 of 2007 filed at the instance of the
landlord/applicant. By the said order, we had dismissed the Special Leave
Petition but granted time to the tenants/contemnors to vacate the premises in
question by 31st of March, 2008, in which the contemnors were tenants under the
landlord/applicant. In the aforesaid order, we also directed the
tenants/contemnors to file an undertaking to vacate the premises on conditions
i.e. (i) to pay all arrears of rent and (ii) to deliver peaceful and vacant
khas possession to the landlord/applicant on the expiry of the period mentioned
In compliance with the above said direction, an undertaking was
filed in this Court by the tenants/contemnors saying that they shall vacate the
premises by 31st of March, 2008 and also pay the arrears of rent. However, this
order has not been complied with. Although the time to vacate the premises had
expired on 31 st of March, 2008, but the possession has been delivered to the
landlord/applicant only on 14th of July, 2009, that is, after filing the
contempt application before us. In our view, the aforesaid facts would clearly
show that the conduct of the tenants/contemnors is contemptuous and therefore,
strong action should be taken and proceeding for contempt should be initiated
against them. But considering the fact that the possession of the premises in
question has already been delivered, though belatedly, we feel it proper in the
facts and circumstances of the case, not to initiate the contempt proceeding
against the tenants/contemnors but only to direct them to pay all the arrears
of rent to the landlord/applicant and in addition to pay cost of Rs.30,000/- to
the landlord/applicant for illegally and deliberately delaying in delivering
possession of the premises in question in spite of filing an undertaking in
this Court. Such payment shall be made within 4 weeks from this date.
In default, put up for further orders. In the event, the amount,
as directed above, is paid to the landlord/applicant, the application for
contempt shall stand disposed of.
will be no order as to costs in the Contempt Application.
...............................J. [TARUN CHATTERJEE]