Nimisha Batish Vs.
Maj Ajay Batish & Ors.  INSC 2149 (12 December 2008)
JURISDICTION TRANSFER PETITION(C) NO. 726 OF 2008 ORDER The petitioner is the
wife and the respondent is the husband. The respondent has filed a petition
under Section 6 of the Hindu Minority and Guardianship Act read with Section 25
of Guardianship and Ward Act for custody of the minor son against his wife, in
the Court of Civil Judge (Senior Division), Gurgaon.
is permanently residing at Mumbai. She has filed this petition seeking transfer
of the above-mentioned case from Gurgaon to Mumbai. The objection of the
respondent is that in another transfer petition relating to a then pending
divorce proceedings, the parties had entered into compromise agreeing for
divorce by mutual consent and one of the terms of the said compromise was that
the case of custody of minor son shall be decided by Gurgaon court; and that,
therefore, the Court at Gurgaon shall alone decide the matter.
When the terms of the
said compromise are read, it is clear that the intention was not to confer
-2- jurisdiction on
the Civil Judge (Senior Division), Gurgaon where the custody dispute was
pending, but to merely express that there was no compromise in regard to that
issue and that since the guardianship case was pending in the Gurgaon Court it
shall be decided by that Court.
party is staying at Gurgaon. The petitioner is residing at Mumbai and the
petitioner is posted abroad. In fact, it will be more convenient for the
respondent to come to Mumbai to prosecute the matter than to go over to
Having regard to the
difficulties faced by the petitioner having a minor son to travel from Mumbai
to Gurgaon for every hearing and having regard to the fact that the respondent
himself is not residing in Gurgaon, we are of the view that this is a fit case
for transfer as prayed for.
direct that Petition No.420/2006 titled Major Ajay (Senior Division), Gurgaon
be trasnferred to the Family Court, Mumbai.
Transfer Petition is
( R.V. RAVEENDRAN )