Arvind Sud Vs. Union of
India & Ors  Insc 596 (25 October 2005)
B.P.Singh, S.B.Sinha &
We have heard counsel for the parties.
It is apparent from our order dated 24th February, 2004 that the only
question which remained to be considered was whether the department has charged
interest from the year 1993 or from any later date. Counsel appearing for the
appellant had then submitted that though the lottery was declared on
12.11.1993, the prize in the form of a Maruti Car was delivered to the
appellant on 8.11.1994 and tax liability arose only thereafter. He was liable
to pay tax only in the assessment year 1995-1996 on receipt basis. Counsel for
the Revenue has produced before us instruction received from the office of the
Chief Commissioner of Income Tax, Ludhiana. The letter dated 24.10.2005 clearly
states that the interest under Section 234A, 234B and 234C was not charged from
the year 1993 as the consideration received on account of lottery prize was
assessed on receipt basis, and not on the declaration of the prize. Thus, there
is no doubt that the interest has been charged on receipt basis and not on the
basis of the date of declaration of the prize.
Counsel for the appellant pointed out that there may be some error of
calculation and in particular, he submitted that the interest, if any, payable
under Section 234B was payable from December, 1995 and not from any earlier
date, since he received the car as a prize on 8.11.1994.
We do not wish to express any considered opinion on this question, since it
is always open to the appellant to move the appropriate authority under Section
154 of the Income Tax Act for appropriate order.
With the above observation, the civil appeal is dismissed.