Vs. State of Madhya Pradesh  INSC 810 (15 July 1996)
K.Ramaswamy, K.G.B. Pattanaik (J)
JT 1996 (6) 651 1996 SCALE (5)474
15TH DAY OF JULY, 1996 Present:
Mr.Justice K.Ramaswamy Hon'ble Mr.Justice G.B.Pattanaik K.T.S. Tulsi,
Additional Solicitor General, (Rajeev Dhavan) Sr. Ad. for Intervenors, Ranjit
Kumar, A.Subba Rao, Anil Katiyar, Uma Nath Singh, E.C.Vidya Sagar, Ms. A. Subhashini,
L.R.Singh, Pramod Kumar and Ms. Vimla Sinha, Advs. with them for the appearing
O R D
following Order of the Court was delivered.
V. State of Madhya Pradesh
O R D
for intervention is allowed.
departed soul of Shri Govind Mukhoty would feel satisfied for the result as he
had done yeomen's service to protect the precious lives of the tribals who used
to go to collect firewood etc. but became victims of firing in the range. He
devoted his life and was an ardent champion of human rights of underprivileged
and one of the cases which he had left over unfinished, is this case which we
are now disposing or partly. In this case, or, account of test firing practices
being organised at a test firing range near Itarasi in Madhya Pradesh, several
of the tribals are becoming victims of the firing and some of them succumb to
the injuries and several sustain grievous injuries. That resulted in filing
this writ petition. This Court, by order dated March 13, 1994 by a Constitution Bench, had accepted the recommendations
made by High-level Committee of the Government constituted pursuant to an order
passed by this Court. The recommendations, as accepted by this Court, are as
The substitute plans of erecting barbed wire fencing around the four target
areas have been worked out and is as per sketch P.,Q. and Q1.
DSC personnel will be deplayed to patrol the target areas to prevent unauthorised
entry by metal pickets into the target area and to protect the barbed wire.
Watch towers will be constructed around the fencing to provide effective field
of observations to the DSC guards to carry out duties at (b) above.
Approach roads to the target areas will be constructed for easy access.
Additional transport will be provided to CPE Itarsi to ferry DSC troops to and
fro target areas and to convey food and other essential requirements to them
while on duty." This Court gave the direction as under:
direct the Government to accord sanction in terms of its own prayer in Criminal
Misc. Petition No.1360/94 immediately so as to allow the tender process to be
completed and the work to commence within 3 months from today. The actual
physical execution of the work for which 24 months' time is indicated in the
aforesaid Note, shall be reduced to and completed in a period of 18
months." For compliance thereof, the matter was adjourned from time to
time and ultimately time was extended by order dated January 12, 1996 to submit full compliance report.
Today, an affidavit has been filed by Brigadier Kuppuswami Ramani who is
in-charge of Central Proof Establishment, Itarasi. As per the report, full
compliance of the directions issued by this Court has been made. We accept the
report and close the matter on implementation part.
writ petition is accordingly disposed of partly.
proceedings in this writ petition are accordingly closed. On maintainability,
reference is awaiting the decision of the Constitution Bench.