Vs. State of Kerala & Anr  INSC 1616 (16 December 1996)
O R D
have heard learned counsel on both sides.
appeal by special leave arises from the judgment of the Division Bench of the Kerala
High Court, made on February
23, 1996 in Writ
Appeal no.13 of 1995.
appellant was working as Reserved Police Constable.
Government notified recruitment to the post of Sub- Inspector from in-service
candidates who were holding Graduation qualification and were within 30 years.
The appellant had applied for the said post but was not considered on the
ground that he was not working in Police Department but was working as
Sub-Inspector in the Special Police Department. Unfortunately, his writ
petition was clubbed with another writ petition wherein it was held that
persons having, already left the service of police Department and serving
elsewhere were not eligible to apply for the post of Sub-Inspector; though
other cases were decided on merits, appellant's case was not considered on
merits. Admittedly, he is working in the Police Department not in the regular
line but in the Special Police Department. The Government Order No.G.O.MS.
No.55/66/Home. dated 11the February, 1966 issued by Home DE (A) Department,
Government of Kerala, Trivandrum indicates thus:
considered the recommendation of the Inspector General of Police in
consultation with the Kerala Public Service Commission, the Government now
direct that all Graduates employed in the police Department, such as Clerks,
Special Branch Assistants, Head Constables, and Police Constables and Officers
of Corresponding rank, within the age of 30 years as on the first day of July
of the year in which applications are invited, will be eligible to apply for
the post of Sub-Inspectors of Police in future." A reading of the above
paragraph would clearly indicate that Graduates who were employed in the Police
Department and were within the age limit of 30 years on the first day of July
of the year were eligible to apply for the post of Sub-inspector of the Police
Department. The enumeration of various posts such as Clerk, Special Branch,
Assistants, Head Constables and Police Constables and Officers of the
corresponding rank would indicate that they are only illustrative and not
exhaustive. Under these circumstances, all the eligible graduates within 30
years working in the Police Department in whatever branch, were eligible to be
considered for the post of Sub-Inspector. Now, the stand for not considering
his case taken by the Government is that he was already promoted as
Sub-Inspector in the Armed Police holding the equivalent rank of Sub-Inspector.
We find no force in the contention. If the appellant seeks to come back to regular
line of Police Department on consideration and if his found to be fit, he is
entitled to be considered. It would be open to him to get selected in
accordance with the procedure. Under these circumstances, the disqualification
now sought to be put is no impediment to consider his candidature. The Public
Service Commission is, therefore, directed to consider his case according to
appeal is allowed. No costs.