of M.P. & Ors Vs. Sadashiv Zamindar
 INSC 571 (18
K.Ramaswamy, K.G.B. Pattanaik (J)
1996 SCC (4) 558 JT 1996 (5) 111 1996 SCALE (4)465
O R D
have heard learned counsel on both sides.
appeal by special leave arises from the order dated May 7, 1993 of the Administrative Tribunal of Madhya Pradesh made in M.A.No.
7/92. The admitted position is that while the respondent was working as Upper
Division Teacher, he claimed the status as a Lecturer. That request came to be
recognized by proceedings dated March 3, 1962 but was decided therein that he was not entitled to the
salary on the principle of " no work, no pay". After his retirement
in 1983, after a considerable delay, the respondent had filed a writ petition
in the High Court claiming all the arrears for the period from 1962 to the date
of the order of notional promotion, viz., January 21,1983. The writ petition was transferred
to the Administrative Tribunal after its re- constitution. Initially, the
Tribunal had dismissed the writ petition by order dated December 27, 1991 on the ground that the claim was
belated. Subsequently, the above review petition came to be filed which was
allowed on merits. Thus this appeal by special leave.
view of the fact that the claim was not adjudicated on merits in the first
instance, it would appear that if the Tribunal found that the earlier order was
not correct, then it would have gone into the merits by giving opportunity to
the State on the questions whether the respondent was entitled to the arrears,
as directed by it on consideration, whether he had discharged the same duties
and whether other cases also would be applicable to the respondent. Since these
questions were not addressed after hearing the appeal and in proper
perspective, we think that the Tribunal has to go in the matter afresh. We do
not propose to go into the matter nor express any opinion on merits.
appeal is accordingly allowed. The order of the Tribunal stands set aside. The
Tribunal is directed to dispose of the matter on merits within six months from
the date of receipt of this order. No costs.